Monday, February 1, 2016

Kid stuck in a Man’s body

In class on Thursday, we touched on a lot of different topics revolving around Hemingway’s character, Krebs, and how his homecoming wasn’t as settling as he wanted it to be. While away fighting, life just seemed simpler. He was a soldier with a set of instructions. All he had to do was do his job, while not getting killed in the process. Although some people might find war a stressful time, I suppose it wasn’t for Krebs. That could just be because his adrenaline was probably rushing 24/7, keeping him in that “fight or flight” mode. It interesting because, when studying the 1950s, we learn about the troubles soldiers had after coming home from the war. After constantly being on the look out for the enemy and wanting to keep alive, coming home to a peaceful environment where all they had to do was sit at a desk from 8-5 was a pretty drastic switch. People almost felt the need to be back in that war situation, physically and psychologically, and so major cases of PTSD sprung up as many men’s minds, in response to the lack of a war environment at home, brought the war back home.

Now, it would be an easy assumption to say that Krebs has PTSD, but I think his condition goes a little more in depth than the normal case. It seems as though Krebs wants his time in and before the war back, but not the militaristic side. Before the war, Krebs understood things. At the war, Krebs, again, understood things. But now, both things have changed as he has returned to his hometown and even the girls are different. According to Krebs, the world around him is changing, leaving him behind to wonder what has happened. Unfortunately, for Krebs, no one else understands his predicament. He is forced to tell lies in order to get someone to listen to him. So, Krebs figures he’s done with it all. He’s done trying to catch up with things he doesn’t feel is necessary. Of course, he does state that he wants a girlfriend, but he doesn’t want to have to work for one. He doesn’t feel the need to change in order to have one. To put a sappy side to it, he just wanted to be true to himself, and if a girl likes that kind of quality, she can decide to be with him. (Honestly, we should just call up Disney right now).

I suppose we should feel a little proud of Krebs for staying true to himself and not trying to be with the crowd. I would have almost been completely rooting for him if it had not been for his conversation with his mother. Although she was nagging him a little, something I definitely would not have appreciated, she did come from the side of a loving, caring mother who just wants her son to live a healthier lifestyle. Granted, she isn't’ really aware of what is going on in Krebs mind, but she’s just trying to help him adjust to life back at home. The way Krebs just blows her off and first says that he doesn’t love her (which I suppose goes hand-in-hand with his whole not lying phase), and then decides to watch his sister’s softball game instead of visiting his dad in his office. As Mr. Mitchell says, he does seem like a childish response: Blowing off one’s adult responsibilities to go watch sports or something. But, honestly, it almost fits in with how Krebs has been treated his entire life. Although we only get this little snippet of his life, it seems as though Krebs has been treated like a child all throughout his upbringing. Using words like “mommy” and having to get permission to take the car out seems almost like what a teenager would have to do, not a full grown man who has just returned home from the war.

One could also argue that Krebs’ mentality of wanting things in the world to come to him, not the other way around, could also be seen as less of a revelation and more of a man who is stuck in the past. As a kid, we sometimes believe that money grows on trees, our parents are superheroes, and things will just come easily to us. But, as we grow older and are forced to make our own way in the world, we see that life just isn’t that easy. By living at home and have the seemingly cradling parents, Krebs has yet to leave the nest and explore the world for himself. I feel like, until he moves out of his parents’ house, he will always be forced to be mamma’s boy and won’t fully mature and figure out how to work in the world he lives in.

All in all, I feel sympathetic for Krebs that he feels trapped inside, unable to speak to anyone about his true feelings. But I also feel like it’s time for him to grow up a little. I realize that sounds a little mean but his parents and their comfortingly stable income won't always be there to help him survive. He needs to put on his big-boy pants to find his way in the world before it completely leaves him behind. (Respectively, of course, because he still is a struggling veteran trying to making understandable adjustments).

4 comments:

  1. The dynamic between Krebs and his mother and (absent) father is, I think, a big part of what he means when he says that nothing really has changed since he's been away. Despite having been through the classic coming-of-age trials of war, he's still being *treated* as a child by his parents. The father seems an especially looming presence--even though he's never physically present in the story, we get a sense of the big shadow he casts, as Krebs can't even browse the sports pages without being reminded not to "muss" the paper, because his father can't very well read a mussed paper, now can he? As unkind as his reflexive response to his mother is, when he declares that he doesn't love her (and follows it with the more revealing claim that he doesn't love *anybody*), it's pretty easy to see why he feels so constrained in this context. He still seems like a child because his "adulthood" remains unacknowledged by his parents. And thus he carries around this weight of his experience in the war--all these stories never told, so to speak--so they still see him as the naive guy in those prewar photos.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I agree with Mr. Mitchell. Something I found really odd about this story was that Krebs's parents treat him like a child. I can't wrap my head around that -- how can you not treat a war veteran as an adult?? The conversation about the war, the word "mommy," and the nagging all contribute to this.

    ReplyDelete
  3. A topic brought up in class was that potentially Krebs was naive to the expectations of society, but I agree with you that Krebs was making an active choice to stay "true to himself". War had shown him who he was minus all the societal pressures and Krebs didn't really feel the need to fake it anymore.
    It's also interesting that you brought up the idea of simplicity in the two differing arenas of Krebs' life. Krebs does seem to make it sound like war is "simpler" than life back at home, but that seems to go against logic or common understanding. Maybe war is just so chaotic and crazy that the way to cope is to streamline your focus to one simple thing- surviving. But back at home, Krebs is unable to find the one simple thing to focus on and therefore must listen/grapple with the complexities of society.

    ReplyDelete
  4. It definitely seems like Kreb's parents foster, to some degree, his willingness to stay at home. It is neither party's fault, that Krebs is facing issues with his lifestyle after the war, but it is clear that his parents' attitude make it seem like Krebs needs someone to push him out into real-life again.

    ReplyDelete